News

Republicans Overtweet

Twitter shuts down 33 fake accounts created by state Republicans in an attempt to lambast Dems

Comments (43)
Tuesday, October 20, 2009

Barack Obama's victory last year left many Republicans bemoaning their party's ineptitude when it came to political exploitation of the Web. Democrats, they admitted, were far ahead in the art of using the Internet to seduce voters.

So Connecticut Republicans decided it was time to boldly forge into the 21st century, only to stumble when one of their decidedly deceptive experiments ran into trouble last week.

Twitter, Inc., shut down 33 fake Twitter accounts created by Republicans using the names of Democratic state representatives. The Republican scheme was to send out posts under the Democrats' names mocking the liberal tax-and-spend bastards.

"That's unfortunate," was state Republican Chairman Chris Healy's response when told of Twitter, Inc.'s decision. "I'm not quite sure what the issue is, other than that the Democrats were successful in stopping free speech."

Healy's party may have suffered a setback with the loss of its Twitter campaign, but Republicans are still operating the 33 Web sites they created using the names of those same Democratic lawmakers. As far as anyone knows, this is the first time any state party has used such a tactic to mock its state opponents.

"It's our idea, actually," said Healy. He said Republicans want voters to understand how badly they're being screwed by the Democrats who approved billions in new taxes rather than cut spending.

Healy has no intention of shutting those sites down just because of Democratic protests.

"They didn't think of it first, so that's why they're whining," Healy said.

But it's not only Democrats who say the GOP's Internet policies are misleading.

According to Twitter, Inc., the fake posts violated the immensely popular social networking system's anti-impersonation policy.

In an e-mail reply to a Democratic legislative leader's complaint, a Twitter representative stated:

"A person may not impersonate others through the Twitter service in a manner that does or is intended to mislead, confuse or deceive others. ... Impersonation is against our terms unless it is a parody. The standard for defining parody is, 'Would a reasonable person be aware that it's a joke?' "

"Because this is not the case in your situation, we have removed the profile(s) from circulation."

"That's silly," Healy said of the decision. "That's not impersonation; that's satire."

Some of the targets of the fake Twitter messages disagree.

Matthew Lesser is a 26-year-old rookie Democratic lawmaker from Middletown who was one of the House legislators Twitterized by the GOP. He was also the first to ask Twitter to kill the GOP account using his name.

Lesser isn't surprised he was one of the Democrats chosen by the GOP.

"It's no secret I'm going to be a targeted Democrat next year," he said.

"Everybody knows Connecticut is a rough and tumble political world," Lesser said. "I support [Republicans'] free speech rights. ... The problem I have is when they cross the line between debate and impersonating opponents."

"It's hard enough to explain what we're doing here in Hartford," said Lesser. "It's even more difficult when you've got political hacks going out of their way to confuse people."

Democrats hold a veto-proof majority in the state House, outnumbering Republicans 114-37. The Democrats also have a 24-12 margin in the state Senate. Those numbers have been frustrating the hell out of GOP leaders, who have seen their share of General Assembly seats shrivel in successive legislative elections.

Their Twitter ploy may have misfired, but Connecticut Republicans aren't giving up on those 33 Web sites created in the names of the Democratic lawmakers. (The fake Twitter posts were linked back to those Web sites.)

All the sites use the same format. In the case of state House Speaker Chris Donovan, D-Meriden, the Republican-funded Web address is meetchrisdonovan.com. All the information on the site was produced by Republicans and is critical of Donovan. The only indication that it was paid for by the state GOP is in small print at the very bottom of the page.

Phillip Simon, director of the Graduate Interactive Communications program at Quinnipiac University, said his impression of the GOP-sponsored sites is that they are misleading.

"It is very deceptive," he said. "It doesn't say anywhere that it's being written by someone else."

Simon said all of the Republicans' anti-Democratic sites use "a lot of pre-made themes" and similar templates, which has dramatically cut down on labor costs for creating and updating the sites.

"Using these relatively low-cost tools to distribute information, whether in an appropriate or inappropriate manner, is going to happen more and more in politics," Simon said.

Rick Hancock is an assistant professor of online journalism and social media at the University of Connecticut who agrees with Simon.

"Personally, I don't think it's ethical," said Hancock, a veteran Connecticut TV journalist. "As a former political reporter, I think it crosses over into dirty politics."

Hancock said the Web sites, unlike those Twitter accounts, don't appear to violate any terms of services or legal restrictions.

Similar Web sites were created during the last presidential election by people on both sides of the political divide, according to Hancock, some spewing venom against the GOP's Sarah Palin, others targeting Obama.

"This is just one additional step," said Hancock.

But Hancock doesn't believe negative political tactics will completely poison the Internet's influence on politics. "I still think it's a positive, powerful tool," he said.

"The truth will eventually come out [about such ploys as the GOP's anti-Democratic sites]," Hancock added. He said the GOP scheme will backfire "if the Republicans are being viewed as playing dirty tricks, dirty politics."

Healy is unrepentant: "I really don't care what a bunch of college professors from liberal colleges think."

 

 

More News Articles
Birth of a Blowhard:  Did Glenn Beck hatch his plan to become a right-wing radio megastar right here on Connecticut's airwaves?
Immobilized:  A pre-schooler in the West Hartford public school system is made to wear a weight vest for being too wiggly

Comments (43)
Post a Comment
Someone needs to show Healy that "turnabout is fair play" and that internet vengeance is rapid and unstoppable.

The GOP treats its supporters like they are a group of brain dead five year olds.
Posted by matt on 10.21.09 at 16.26
Not a lot different from the Democrats telling liberal tweeters not to put their state or change location so they can send tweets to multiple Legislators. It's all disgusting and inappropriate.
Posted by Jorge on 10.21.09 at 16.55
I agree sending multiple tweets to legislators using deception is wrong, but that hardly rises to the level of these republicans impersonating congress people on the internet.
Personally, I think someone should impersonate Healy on the net and post pornographic photos of him. Let's see how Healy feels about that scenario. After all, it just be satire.
Posted by karlaw on 10.21.09 at 18.25
I find a new reason every day to hate Republicans. I cannot wait for their base (the elderly) to finally die off.
Posted by Josh on 10.21.09 at 19.36
Can you share the list of those 33 accounts?

I need it for research.

Thanks, Ovi
Posted by Ovi on 10.21.09 at 20.16
Geez - how lame an excuse is that, Jorge? Yeah, this is exactly like what the Democrats do. Except it isn't at all like anything that the Democrats have done, and it's completely sleazy and probably illegal.

Impersonating a police officer is a crime, impersonating an ordinary citizen is identify theft. I don't see how impersonating an elected official is anything different. If you can't see that it's unethical, you've got problems.

Of course, ethics are notoriously liberal. And Republicans are the party of good values! Like lying!
Posted by Brian on 10.21.09 at 20.24
Impersonating the opposition is not the same as satirizing them. Chris Healy does a good job conflating the two.

Impersonating (not unlike stealing their letterhead and sending a mailing in their name) is also called rat-fucking.

It is dishonorable and if they had done it through the US mail, they'd be looking at a criminal record and jail time.

Imagine being a Republican and thinking the best way to spend your time was to dishonestly make you opponent look bad.
Posted by Neil Sagan on 10.21.09 at 20.50
It's all they got.
Posted by Neil Sagan on 10.21.09 at 20.52
http://foxnewsboycott.com/resources/fox-can-lie-lawsuit/
Posted by Neil Sagan on 10.21.09 at 20.53
The GOP sucks, period. They are despicable people who are either plotting evil deeds or are stupid sheep following the plotters. Their racist, sexist, xenophobic and homophobic agenda is beyond disgusting.

Check me out on twitter: http://www.twitter.com/theGOPsucks
Posted by The GOP Sucks on 10.21.09 at 21.55
Maybe they should have just illegally stole these Democrats credit reports...oh wait, that's Chuck Schumer's (D-Asshole) schtick..
Posted by Lol on 10.21.09 at 21.59
Looking for the identical sites? Each started either 2/10/09 or 6/10/09 http://tinyurl.com/yjguw7f
Posted by Justin Case on 10.21.09 at 22.00
You liberals are a bunch of whiny, hate filled losers. You guys control EVERYTHING in Washington, even the media. You would think you wouldn't be such whiners with that kinda power. Gotta have a boogeyman though to scare the people into voting for you because your shit polices sure aren't enough.
Posted by Lordy on 10.21.09 at 22.01
Aren't there campaign laws being violated here?
Posted by planetspinz on 10.21.09 at 22.46
Calling deception or ridicule "satire" has long been the refuge of political cowards and unskilled debate. This kind of dirty politics is offensive to those of us who believe in the greater potential of our system. CT Republicans should be ashamed of themselves and of their compatriots.
Posted by BD on 10.22.09 at 5.08
Republicans are... lying?! The sky is... blue?!

No surprise here, jackasses all of them.
Posted by a on 10.22.09 at 5.28
Hey Justin Case. We just got out of a freaking 8 year GOP junta that nearly destroyed our country. Dems have been in office 9 MONTHS. read it...9 Months. Wev'e controlled "everything" for 9 months. and how the hell is Fox news liberal??? You're just mad cause you're people lost which makes you a LOSER! Live with it...we had to live with your barely literate ass clown posse bigot pals for 8 years....read 8 years. It's called a democracy. someone wins...someone loses.
Posted by astrosmash on 10.22.09 at 5.36
posting allocation is counterintuitive here. last missive was meant for "Lordy" (figures) sorry Justin Case.
Posted by astrosmash on 10.22.09 at 5.37
The GOP lied to us about Saudi Arabia and we invaded Afghanistan. The GOP lied to us about WMDs, Yellow Cake and ignored massive African genocide in favor of Saddam's genocide, and we invaded Iraq.

This doesn't surprise me one bit. It's a page out of Fox News' book where they sometimes 'goof' put a (D) after the name of yet another disgraced Republican during his perp walk.

Tsk Tsk hateful backwards underachieving GOPers.

Posted by FatSean on 10.22.09 at 6.47
I suppose I should feel outraged by this, but mostly I think it's pathetic.
Posted by agio on 10.22.09 at 7.37
"The Republican scheme was to send out posts under the Democrats' names mocking the liberal tax-and-spend bastards."

This story is filed under "news". Why?
Posted by Ben on 10.22.09 at 9.12
"You liberals are a bunch of whiny, hate filled losers. You guys control EVERYTHING in Washington, even the media. You would think you wouldn't be such whiners with that kinda power. Gotta have a boogeyman though to scare the people into voting for you because your shit polices sure aren't enough. "

Oh my word, Lordy, that sounds like a total rehash of the 2004 election!

Fear-mongering is a Rovian trait, just so we are clear.

Lies and deception from the Republicans? Sure beats actually taking the time to come up with ideas and policy I suppose.
Posted by jen on 10.22.09 at 10.49
No wonder only 20% of Americans identify as Republicans now. It is this sort of twisted logic and deception that has destroyed this once great political party.
Posted by Clint on 10.22.09 at 11.09
Dear Mr. Healy:

I realize you're not an attorney - or even smart enough to correctly spell the name of your undergraduate university in your own website's biography (Denision? Really ...?) - but ... um ... the 1st Amendment's "free speech" protections only apply to actions by the government. Last time I checked, Twitter was not an agency of any federal or state government ... Of course contract law applies to all who enter into such arrangements - maybe you should read the next one you sign before you sign it ...

And you may not care what a bunch of liberal college professors think about your dirty pool-playing ... but I'd think you would care what voters and constituents think. You know the UCONN prof is a resident - I'd dare say the Quinnipiac prof is, too. And your down like 22-1 in the comments section of the Advocate piece ...

All-around bang-up job there, buddy!
Posted by BillyH on 10.22.09 at 12.48
"That's silly," Healy said of the decision. "That's not impersonation; that's satire."
SUE, SUE, SUE, and see what the courts think if this is silly! ! The ONLY way to stop this 'silly' illegal crap is to allow a court and a jury to decide and sent a message to all that its not just silly.
wit loVe J Rome
Posted by J Rome on 10.22.09 at 15.06
Sleazy tactics by Republicans? Check.
Whining about free speech (not applicable on Twitter, of course) when you get caught? Check.
Backlash at the next election? Priceless.
Posted by Shayes on 10.23.09 at 5.37
Um, that's not free speech, it's libel.
Posted by Baker on 10.23.09 at 9.43
Most GOPers have trouble using their TV clicker no less trying to use Twitter in a dishonest and clandestine manner. Is anyone surprised that they failed? A lame and dying breed.
Posted by greybees on 10.23.09 at 10.29
More "dirty tricks" by the GOP. Ol' Tricky Dick Nixon must be proud of them.

And they wonder why voter identification with the Republicans has fallen to a record-low 20 percent nationally (I'm not going to venture a guess as to how low it is in Connecticut).

But that's what happens when you allow the lunatic fringe take over your party.
Posted by Skeeter Sanders on 10.23.09 at 16.58
GOP, please read the constitution. I'm sure you can find a copy online somewhere, because you clearly don't own one. The rights set out in the constitution's bill of rights apply limitations to the government, not to private business. Sheesh. Get a clue or get out of government, please, for the good of the country.
Posted by emmi on 10.27.09 at 5.53
What's up with the style in which this article was written? Liberal tax and spend bastards? What the hell? Is that a quote? Is that yours?

Journalism 101 anyone?
Posted by Ken on 10.27.09 at 7.23
Isn't that identity theft...knowingly using someone else's name. If I were one of the people whose names they STOLE I would prosecute. At once.
Posted by Marge on 10.27.09 at 8.03
"I cannot wait for their base (the elderly) to finally die off. " Posted by karlaw on 10.21.09 at 18.25

I feel that way a lot, then I realize my aging parents are part of the Repubican Base.

The problem is, I think, that certain groups of people in the elderly generation cannot believe that the Republicans believe what they say they believe. their ideal of Republicans, and their trust in federal government officials, is fixed somewhere in the middle of the late 20th century.
Posted by Wolfgang1453 on 10.27.09 at 8.20
MeetChrisHealy.com is available for the taking. I think someone with ten bucks and a couple hours of spare time could have a field day with this GOP operative. I'm from NY, so others should have at it.
Posted by Teddy on 10.27.09 at 8.37
I assume "liberal tax and spend bastards" is a characterization of the type of mocking done by the Republicans, and not an editorial comment by the author. Still, it's probably better not to use irony in a straight news article.
Posted by dougjay on 10.27.09 at 8.39
wow. just wow.

how long has it been since this "news" went up? Even Wonkette has already posted about it.

And you STILL haven't corrected the "tax and spend bastards" statement?

I smell Pulitzer.
Posted by rb on 10.27.09 at 9.18
Agreed on bad journalism of tax-and-spend bastards but the facts that point at GOP sucking are still poignant.

"The GOP treats its supporters like they are a group of brain dead five year olds."

After 30 years of appealing to the lowest common denominator, that's all they have left. Fortunately even conservatives hate lip service and will find a new game if that's all they've ever gotten and I would say, yes, that is in fact all they've gotten since Reagan.

It has to be about something more than binary xenophobia, and then reducing taxes while exponentially increasing spending every damn time.
Posted by Erik on 10.27.09 at 10.31
Oh, well, satire, that's OK.

Why doesn't this article mention the reports that Mr Healy raped and murdered a girl in 1990?
Posted by RK on 10.27.09 at 17.15
This is entirely appropriate of Twitter, and Healy is being either deliberately facetious, naive or worse, stupid as to believing that a private service like Twitter has to honor his "free speech"---does he know anything about Republican values? They would never allow the government to interfere in private enterprise like that. Of course Twitter can cancel them for a TOS violation.

He was not creating satire. This is the Glenn Beck defense--"Oh hey, just a joke!". Unlike Beck, he was impersonating with intent to defraud voters.
Posted by Alex on 10.27.09 at 19.49
I'm in high school, and even I think this is juvenile! This is something you would do in grade school.
Posted by Mia on 10.28.09 at 6.37
you shitheads "tax and spend bastards", its a joke, not an error
Posted by sandyvag on 11.5.09 at 9.57
Exactly how do the Republicans dare to call the Dens tax and spenders when we're mired in the greatest national debt in the history of the Republic after 8 years of Republican control?
Posted by fink on 11.13.09 at 19.55
http://rapid4me.com>" target="_blank" rel="nofollow">http://rapid4me.com> http://rapid4me.com
Posted by dana on 11.18.09 at 5.58
Leave this field empty Name*:

Email*:

URL:

Comment:

All comments must adhere to our Terms & Conditions of Use.

Find it Here:
keyword:
search type:
search in:

« Previous   |   Next »
Print Email RSS feed

The Devil in the Details
Sure, Lieberman pissed off liberals by killing the public option. But there’s more to the story. Here’s the whole truth and what it means for Connecticut.
Immobilized
A pre-schooler in the West Hartford public school system is made to wear a weight vest for being too wiggly
No Sex Offenders
Greenwich ponders restricting where registered sex offenders can go
Nightmare Memory
A witness to Eugenio DeLeon Vega’s slaying says she didn’t say what she said
Cuffed in Pittsburgh
A former Army medic says police stripped him of his insignia and patches during the G-20 summit
Freegan Out
From second-hand clothes to foraging in fields to grabbing dinner out of trash bins, freegans try to take as little as possible from the consumer world
Water World
Will the new expanded bottle deposits mean more money flooding into the state? Critics doubt it.
Crime and Punishment
Round-up of local crimes